JAY KELLY – THE TRUTH THAT REMAINS WHEN THE MYTH FADES

–

After Jay Kelly ‘s Venice premiere , in that strange suspended atmosphere where a film still seems to vibrate before truly belonging to the world, I finally had the chance to rewatch it calmly, at home. Far from the festival ritual, the expectations and immediate interpretations, the film reveals another side: more intimate, more fragile, more sincere. Rewatched two or three times, its subtle lines emerge, those narrative cracks where Baumbach constructs his emotional truth.

There’s a moment in Jay Kelly where the protagonist says, “All my memories are movies.” It’s a seemingly light-hearted phrase, because it captures the heart of this dramedy: the exact point where real life and the life depicted blur together, especially for those who have inhabited their public image for too long. Baumbach doesn’t work on myth: he works on the fracture of myth, on the space that opens up when the character ceases to be a role and is no longer, entirely, a person.

In some passages, an almost Fellini-esque tone emerges. Not in the form, but in the ability to dissolve the boundary between memory and representation. There’s an internal rhythm, an emotional cadence reminiscent of that cinema in which biography becomes a visionary self-portrait, and the protagonist observes his own life as if he were watching it from outside, already transformed into a story.

George Clooney plays Jay Kelly with surprising restraint: he doesn’t defend anything, he doesn’t cling to the star he once was, he lets the camera slide over him with both rawness and tenderness. Baumbach gives him close-ups that don’t embellish, that don’t protect, and he responds with a vulnerability that liberates him, rather than exposes him. It’s perhaps his most permeable role: a man who encounters the ghost of his previous roles and no longer knows which of the two is more authentic.

The film follows his inner turmoil without fitting them into a traditional narrative: the professional void that comes after the end of a film shoot, the distance from his daughters, the mourning of a mentor, a trip to Europe that becomes a corridor of uncomfortable truths. Every event, every encounter, every line seems like a fragment of an emotional mosaic that no longer fits together.

Alongside Clooney, Adam Sandler creates a magnetic presence: the assistant who for years has kept his practical life afloat, the machine of relationships, deadlines, mistakes, alibis. Sandler doesn’t steal the scene: he completes it. He fills it with a weary loyalty, an affection no longer knowing how to express itself, that mixture of devotion and impatience typical of those who have lived too close to the fire. Laura Dern closes the triangle with impeccable clarity, bringing to the film that ability to tell the truth with a half-smile that doesn’t save, but clarifies.

Jay Kelly isn’t a perfect film, and that’s precisely its strength. Baumbach doesn’t aim for completeness: he aims for sincerity. When he stumbles into sentimentality, it’s because the character has no defenses left. When he verges on meta-cinema, it’s because Kelly himself no longer distinguishes between what he experienced and what he interpreted. This isn’t an artifice: it’s the very nature of the subject matter.

The final tribute, in which the protagonist’s life unfolds through actual sequences from Clooney’s filmography, is the culmination of the hall of mirrors. A life experienced as if it were a film, and a film experienced as if it were a life. “Can I start over?” Kelly asks, looking into the camera. At that point, it no longer matters who’s speaking: the character, the actor, or the man wondering what remains when the legend crumbles.

Jay Kelly is a film that doesn’t surprise, but it endures. It doesn’t aim to be great cinema: it aims to be a true, untidy, human portrait. It’s a work that breathes, that leaves space, that looks at fragility without judgment. And truth, when uncompressed, doesn’t dazzle: it illuminates.

–

–
–